|
Lake Minatare: A
Surprising Discovery
Photos and text by Bob Grier
At first, fishing in this wide spot of an old
irrigation system doesn't appear promising, but look
again. Careful forage fish management and newly
constructed reefs--adding structure and
habitat--have turned this 2,158-acre reservoir into
a promising Panhandle fishery.
A Colorado angler overheard fishermen in a
store talking about great walleye fishing in the Panhandle.
But, because he didn't remember the name of the lake, he
called Jack Peterson, district fisheries supervisor at the
Nebraska Game and Parks Commission office in Alliance.
Peterson, who regularly handles requests
for fishing information, told the caller the lake could be
Lake Minatare. The next afternoon, Peterson unexpectedly got
another call from the same fisherman. This time, he wanted
to report his success.
"He said they towed their boat to Minatare
that morning and found anglers with limits of walleyes
loading their boats. In the distance they saw a group of
boats on the lake and fishermen landing fish. He said both
of them were back at the dock within an hour with their
limits of walleyes."
Fishing was exceptional that morning - one
of those rare times anglers remember well and retell often -
but, it was not unique. In recent years, Lake Minatare has
developed a surprising reputation for success among anglers.
It's especially surprising given the
lake's almost featureless sandy shoreline and bottom, its
severe drawdown during the summer irrigation season and the
large number of anglers who are attracted to the only
sizeable reservoir in the central Panhandle. With 2,158
surface acres when full, Lake Minatare supports a
multi-species fishery, including walleye, channel catfish,
crappie, yellow perch, wiper, smallmouth bass and white
bass.
Minatare was built as an irrigation
reservoir in 1915, part of a system known as the "inland
lakes," which includes three other lakes and water-delivery
canals. Essentially a wide spot in the water-delivery
system, Minatare is a highly productive fishery despite the
heavy irrigation drawdowns from it. Its water turnover rate
is one of the fastest in the state. From May, when the lake
is full, to the end of the irrigation season in
late-September, Minatare loses an average of 52 percent of
its water volume. Other Nebraska reservoirs might take three
years or more for outflows to exceed their storage
capacities.
Minatare's irrigation water is managed
differently than most other irrigation reservoirs. Water is
delivered to Minatare from the Interstate Canal flowing from
a diversion dam on the North Platte River located at Whalen,
Wyoming, near the town of Fort Laramie. As irrigation winds
down, usually in late-August or early-September, the lake is
partially refilled before winter. In spring, it is filled to
capacity, just before the irrigation season begins again.
"The drawdowns and filling cycles
definitely affect walleye, Lake Minatare's most important
game fish," said Peterson. "Walleye have critical spawning
habitat requirements, including shallow beds of small rock
and crushed concrete where the eggs can filter into the
cracks and crevices and where moving water provides
aeration. Lake Minatare's bottom is mostly sand with very
little hardpan.

Biologists Al hanson (left) and Jack Peterson
mark, record and determine the sex of each
walleye they collect during a study to find out
how many fish use new Minatare reefs and
windrows. This unusual nighttime photo was taken
using a four-second exposure followed by a
flash. What appear to be flames are spotlights
located behind the biologists (who moved during
the exposure) and reflections off the water in
the tub. The walleye was caught in midair by the
flash after being tossed toward the lake.
|
About the only suitable walleye spawning
habitat was the small rock used to armor the base of the
dam. Walleye will usually spawn around the end of March or
the first of April, depending on water temperatures. Spring
filling of the lake usually begins in mid-April.
Unfortunately, there are years that the low-water levels
leave the rock high and dry during the walleye-spawning
period and natural reproduction is severely limited."
Because spawning success varies from year
to year, fisheries biologists supplement the walleye's
natural reproduction at Minatare by stocking fingerlings
every other year - part of a long-term, statewide study of
walleye. Annually biologists sample the walleye population,
using nets and electrofishing equipment to gather fish, and
track walleye year-classes.
The sampling information improves fish
management in the lake. For example, sampling revealed that
gizzard shad, a forage fish, plays a critical role in Lake
Minatare's productivity. In 1992, gizzard shad failed to
spawn in the lake, and sampling in subsequent years showed
nearly complete losses of year-classes of walleye, yellow
perch, crappie, and even sucker and carp. To ensure an ample
forage base in the lake, gizzard shad are now stocked
annually, and biologists conduct special shad-sampling
projects to track their production and survival.
"We don't see carryover or large gizzard
shad during our samples," Peterson said. "Minatare is on the
northern edge of the gizzard shad's range, and our concern
is high winter mortality. The supplemental stocking of adult
gizzard shad in the reservoir is kind of an insurance
policy. We seine shad from ten different locations in the
lake each summer and check the size of young-of-the-year
fish as part of the on-going walleye study. Our fall
sampling finds very few shad survive to age one or two. We
also use graph-recording sonar to provide additional
information on schooling shad, not only the numbers of
schools but the size of the schools help to identify the
lake's shad base going into the fall, winter and spring.
"We also find an emerald shiner presence
in Minatare, probably from upstream stockings in Wyoming
reservoirs on the North Platte River. The emerald shiners
don't appear to have a detrimental effect at this time, but
they are predators for the smaller aquatic organisms that
young-of-the-year game fish require."
Lake Minatare's forage base creates a
fast-growing walleye population; they reach 7.4 inches at
the end of their first year, 13.2 inches by the next year
and 16.5 inches by the end of the third growing season. The
average four-year- old walleye is 18.6 inches. Minatare
samples show very few walleyes exceeding 20 inches -
probably because of fishing pressure. What is certain is
that walleyes exceeding the 15-inch keeper minimum are
extremely popular with anglers.
The forage base also supports limited
stocking of wiper, a tackle-busting hybrid of the striped
bass and white bass. Minatare receives a small number of
stocked wipers - 5 per acre, or about 10,000 wipers - every
other year.
Peterson believes the wipers offer a bonus
trophy fish to Minatare anglers. Recent sampling indicates
Minatare has a larger than normal year-class of wipers
exceeding five pounds - a fact that should mean good or
excellent wiper fishing for the next several years. Anglers
are also taking increasing numbers of smallmouth bass and
the lake has an underutilized channel catfish fishery.
In 1998, Lake Minatare received the first
major aquatic-habitat construction project in Nebraska's
Panhandle. Contractors laid down nearly 8,600 tons of
crushed concrete and cobble rock, creating aquatic reefs
along the lake's Lighthouse Point and dam.
Funded by the Aquatic Habitat Stamp
program and Nebraska Environmental Trust grants, the project
provided additional structure and habitat for spawning
walleyes and other fish species, and for organisms in the
aquatic food chain.
Two reefs, separated by a 100-foot buffer,
were built below the lighthouse, each 176 feet long and 213
feet wide, or about 37,500 square feet. Broken concrete was
used to form the north reef; the south reef was constructed
of cobble rock - gravel two to six inches in diameter -
excavated nearby.
The location, dimensions and elevation of
the aquatic reefs were designed with Lake Minatare's
changing water levels in mind.
"The lake's water elevation usually varies
almost 20 vertical feet during the irrigation season,"
Peterson said. "The sites and elevations selected ensures
that rock will be available as the

Near Lighthouse Point, a broken concrete aquatic
reef, which offers spawning habitat for walleyes
in spring, was completed before Lake Minatare's
water level rose in the fall.
|
reservoir's water levels rise and fall. Using both crushed
concrete and cobble rock reefs gave us the opportunity to
evaluate their use by spawning walleye for future habitat
improvement projects."
In addition to the reefs, contractors
created triangle-shaped windrows of cobble rock, 11/2 foot
high on a 41/2- to five-foot base, around the tip of
Lighthouse Point. Totaling 7,230 feet in length, the 48
windrows are separated by five-foot gaps. They provide
aquatic habitat for fish, invertebrates and other organisms.
Cobble rock was also placed along the dam
during the fall when the lake was down. The windrows and
aquatic reefs are marked with buoys to alert boaters to the
presence of underwater structures.
Peterson and Al Hanson, also a Commission
biologist, sampled walleye during the 2000 spawning period
to determine their use of the new reefs and windrows. They
used electrofishing equipment mounted on a boat to
temporarily stun fish in an area so they could be collected.
The sampling was done during three nights in April,
approximately a week apart.
Each night the researchers began sampling
at sundown, spending equal time on each reef and nearby
control areas. Several electrofishing passes were made over
each area. All the captured walleye were transported away
from the study area and marked to identify those recaptured
later. The researchers also determined and recorded the sex
of each fish.
During the three nights of sampling, the
number of walleyes collected on the aquatic reefs totaled
868, of which 73 were recaptures. They collected 524
walleyes, or 60 percent of the total, over the cobble reef,
and 344 fish, or 40 percent, from the crushed concrete reef.
"We also made one electrofishing pass over
cobble rock on the face of the dam to count walleye,"
Peterson said. "A total of 375 walleyes were observed along
this 800-foot section. We also made several survey passes
over the windrowed area, but high winds that night made it
difficult to accurately sample. But, it was apparent that
walleye numbers on the windrowed sites were lower than on
the aquatic reefs."
The recent aquatic reef projects at Lake
Minatare have provided important submerged structure and
habitat for game fish and other aquatic organisms. For the
future, these projects and on-going efforts to assure an
ample forage base should provide Nebraska Panhandle anglers
excellent fishing opportunities and enhance Lake Minatare's
reputation as a surprising fishery. |